Sun, Mar-29-15, 09:42
|
|
Senior Member
Posts: 5,314
|
|
Plan: very low carb real food
Stats: 245/125/135
BF:
Progress: 109%
Location: Vermont
|
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Liz53
I actually find Bernstein and Fung to be complementary. I don't hear Dr Bernstein talking as much about lowering insulin as I hear him talking about lowering blood sugar. Though Bernstein certainly mentions insulin and its effects (I've read a couple of his books as well), it was Dr Fung that really drove home for me that diabetes is about insulin resistance, reframing high blood sugar as a symptom rather than the disease itself. One thing I noticed is that Dr B attributed insulin resistance to obesity - which is not far from the idea that being overweight *causes* obesity. It makes me wonder if he would agree with Dr Fung that insulin resistance is the root cause of diabetes.
I skipped Marc David, will go back and listen on your recommendation.
|
Complementary is probably a better way to put it than first and second. Dr Fung definitely opened my eyes to insulin resistance as a root cause of diabetes. I think obesity is both cause and effect, with the trigger a high carb diet, since the process seems to be cyclical. This is certainly not something Dr Bernstein has elucidated sufficiently. He is the one who turned me on to low carb eating and its relationship to blood glucose levels so I remain loyal especially since it still works. I think perhaps that Dr Fung doesn't pay as much attention as he could to keeping bg levels low and Dr Bernstein doesn't talk enough about insulin resistance, so yes, complementary.
I hope you like Marc David. I wasn't prepared to like him but I did like his message of using whatever comes our way, and things always come our way, as opportunities, that being mired in victimhood and poor me is counter-productive to a happy fulfilling life.
Jean
|