Hi! My name's Rudi and I would have to say that I am very concerned after reading this discussion.
Please bear with me if you can because I'm trying to give the best picture possible of my background and why I am concerned about the need for supplements with the LC diets.
All of the Atkins hoopla says that you have no trouble keeping the weight off because you never increase really the amount of carbs. Now I read form Nat that despite LCing and plenty of exercise, her metabolism is very low. Trainer Dan feels it neccessary to go on ephedrine-laced supplements to stay pumped up, despite CKD trimming him down?
If I stay on this WOE for years, will I eventually have to do even more tricks to my metabolism than Atkins to keep the weight off? Personally, I am against these supplements because I don't know how you can ever stop taking them. Once you stop, doesn't the weight just come back on? What will happen in 10 or 20 years when you don't want to put up with taking the supplements anymore, cyclically or not?
Let me give you some background: I went on a similar diet to Atkins about 5 years ago for six months and lost 50 lbs, which went back on plus interest since then, in spite of watching what I ate and exercising. I just went back on Atkins last Monday and have lost 7 pounds so far. I feel great, energized, and am committed to doing this for years. I know that my metabolism changed when I was on the diet and that after my body believed I was "starving", the weight was definitely going to come back on.
HOWEVER, five years ago when I went off Atkins, I had decided to work at my body image and stop the cycle of weight loss and re-gain, to love myself. I was 230 lbs at the time I went off the diet, with a body fat % of 21. My LBM was about 180, and for a woman at 5'6", that LBM is kind of impressive, I think. I have always worked about a lot (cardio mostly 5-6 days/week) and have built up this muscle mass over time. I have a large frame with heavy bones, and that is not just an excuse for being fat -- I inherited my dad's frame, and he was a typical defensive football player with the huge shoulders and everything. The muscle mass just allows me to move this heavy body through all the things that I make it do.
Now I am 316 lb and have an LBM of 196, which would mean that my target would be about 240. However, I am hoping that with a lower body mass, the need for all that muscle would lessen and I would also lose a little bit of the muscle mass.
After I went off Atkins, I really worked on my body image and said to myself that it would be okay to be fat, that I would be okay with myself no matter what I looked like. I worked hard at stopping eating when I was full and putting my all into exercising consistently. I did have ankle surgery 3 years ago which held me down for a while, but I am still confused at my body. I feel betrayed that I tried to live the healthiest I could and have continued to add more pounds every year. I'm not saying I have been perfect, but I don't feel I should be this overweight and still gaining.
So, if I do Atkins for a few years with my metabolism, will I start eventually to gain back the weight even despite staying on the diet? Will I have to resort to these supplements to effectively keep the weight off? Does anyone else have experience with a body like mine?