Sat, Mar-16-13, 10:36
|
|
Senior Member
Posts: 6,140
|
|
Plan: Mostly Fung/IDM
Stats: 165/138.4/135
BF:???/better/???
Progress: 89%
Location: Washington state
|
|
I did Stillman's a few times when I was your daughter's age and I found it very very difficult. It is about as low as you can go in carbs, low fat and high protein. That's a difficult (impossible?) combination to maintain on. I can still remember broiling hamburger patties and chicken breasts (ugh), but I'm sure that I was never able to stick to it for more than a week at a time.
The Zone, on the other hand, allows quite a lot of carbs - and I recall is fairly low fat. The carbs will increase appetite and cravings, but if you have to limit fat....again, hard to maintain.
I would recommend Atkins as the perfect middle ground. You start very low carb (20 total carbs or 20 net carbs, depending on which version), and gradually add carbs till you find your tolerance for them, paying careful attention how the additional carbs and new foods affect cravings, hunger and weight loss (or gain. Fat is your friend on Atkins which keeps you satisfied. If your doctor still fears fat, he is wrong. Read Gary Taubes' Why We Get Fat and What to do About It to see what really makes us fat (spoiler alert: it's carbs, NOT fat). Taubes includes a list of foods at the end of the book which is based on Dr Westman's clinic plan, which is in turn based on the original Dr Atkins Diet Revolution from 1972.
South Beach is another plan that I think is sustainable. A little lower fat, and higher carb than Atkins, and since it is written by a leading cardiologist, other doctors seem to be more accepting of it than Atkins. Depending on your daughter's tolerance for carbs, it may be great for her. Again, it starts lower carb, and increases them, though less systematically than Atkins (I personally LOVE the structure of Atkins' carb ladder).
Once you settle on a plan, there are tons of recipes, etc on this website. Both Atkins and South Beach also have their own sites which provide more recipes and meal plans. Whatever you decide on, both you and your daughter should read the book(s) to understand the fine points.
|