I don't know what is really going on, but it sounds pretty unfair. Sorry. It might just be the point that total calories do matter, which stinks. I think going back to induction is a good idea to see it if the weight comes off. I would keep your extra fat in at first, if the weight still doesn't come off then keep the carbs at induction level and also start dropping calories too.

Personally, I think our bodies are less tolerant of carbs as our total calories go up. Good luck... I am sure you will get to the bottom of this.