Wed, May-20-09, 00:03
|
Senior Member
Posts: 746
|
|
Plan: My own low-carb rules
Stats: 190/180/140
BF:
Progress: 20%
Location: Seattle
|
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by capmikee
Homeopathic medicine doesn't make any sense. The principle, in case you're not familiar, is to take a substance that CAUSES a problem, and then dilute it so much that not even a single molecule of it is left. This remedy is then used to CURE the problem that the substance causes.
I was told about some scientist who set out to debunk homeopathy for the obvious swindle that it is. But she was unable to - her experiments suggested that it works, not just by placebo effect!
My feeling is that the way homeopathy really works is not known to its practitioners, but something they're doing is in fact effective. My wife uses arnica pretty frequently. I don't have any reason to use it myself (at least not that I've heard of), so I can't comment on its effectiveness for me personally.
|
I used to work for a naturopathic doctor who stated to me (not his patients) that it was often due to placebo effect. Anyway, you're giving people water or alcohol, depending on the base solution. The added chemicals (whether from herbs or something else) are so dilute, that it's impossible for them to have any effect. Additionally, the "natural" chemical selected is supposed to mimic the symptoms, not counteract them as with modern medicine. Tap water has dilute chemicals. We're exposed to minute quantities of stuff all the time. As for arnica, that's not homeopathy unless it's an extract present in a tiny, almost undetectable quantity in solution.
As for placebo effect -- this is always present in pharmaceutical drug trials, in fact. The placebo effect is very strong. In drug trials, a product is shown to be effective if it has significantly greater efficacy than a placebo.
As for accupuncture -- there are actually double- blind studies that have shown its benefit in certain situations, especially pain control or used instead of anesthesia during surgery. There are animal studies, too. Very interesting. I don't disregard all alternative medicine, just a few things here and there (including homeopathy).
Last edited by fatnewmom : Wed, May-20-09 at 00:11.
|