Quote:
Originally Posted by Janknitz
Your naturopath was probably on the right path--how much carb was allowed on that diet? I'll bet it was organic, whole REAL foods, so at worst all you really needed to do--possibly-was dial down the carbs.
One of the reasons I think that low carb has earned such a bad reputation is that a lot of people who do low carb think it's OK to eat unlimited quantities of processed fake foods and artificial sweeteners. Keep in mind that when Atkins was doing his work in the 1960's and 1970's, there was not the abundance of processed foods we have now, and the only artificial sweetener that was readily available was saccharine (which, IMHO, tasted terrible!).
Low carb isn't about diet sodas, bacon, and cold cuts. People do better on junk food low carb simply because it's an improvement over SAD junk food, but it's not optimal. Low carb, at it's heart, is about reducing the carbs in your diet, and when you do it with healthful whole, real food choices you give your body what it needs instead of a bunch of things it does not.
I would go back to your naturopath's diet since that was working for you, dial back the carbs if it is still higher in carbs (since your naturopath was "insulin reducing" I'm going to guess it was already fairly low carb), up the natural, real fats as necessary. I bet you will see your skin clear up PDQ.
|
I agree, and my skin will probably clear up. My naturopath isn't really into reducing most veggies (other than eliminating root veggies), but he is into eliminating:
chocolate and chocolate flavored anything
![Mad](/images/smilies/mad.gif)
, coffee, caffeinated tea, anything artificial, legumes, fruit, grains, root veggies, yogurt, bacon and cold cuts.
He does like whey protein shakes (however for me, without blueberries or strawberries, I don't really like them), he also recommends lean protein and lots of veggies for most meals, and he says to eat up to 2 avocados a day and lots of eggs. He's also big into nuts (except peanuts as they contain mold) and seeds and coconut oil.
He does not allow diet or sugar free anything! And he's not big on milled flax meal, almond meal, or coconut flower as he says they are too readily digestible
![Spin](/images/smilies/spiny.gif)
.
I do seem to have a tough time losing on this plan now, although in 2006 it worked (and back then I could eat berries, pears, apples, peaches and yogurt).
I only ever got to 175 on that plan though, and only lasted there for 48 hours before jumping back to 177, despite eating to his plan 100% for probably 2 years. I look pretty good at that weight (I'm big boned and have a lot of lean muscle mass) and was wearing a size 10, so it wasn't too bad. Even now I can wear my size 12 jeans but they will fit better when I lose 5-7 lbs.