Sat, Feb-11-12, 19:27
|
Senior Member
Posts: 126
|
|
Plan: Atkins
Stats: 265/231/175
BF:265/231/175
Progress: 38%
|
|
Did some reading, (webmd, etc) and found that the home meters are all reasonably accurate. The +/- 1% error is not that much.
The theory behind the A1c test is that the glucose associated with red blood cells(RBC). RBC circulate for 3 months, so measuring them is an average glucose for, say 1.5 months. The measurement has less fluctuation than a typical non-fasting blood glucose test.
That said, it is extremely expensive to get a very accurate meter. The home systems are cheap and accessible and by definition, slightly inaccurate. The FDA has to approve the systems -- that they are producing a reasonably accurate result. No matter what your opinion of the FDA, these standards are really quite good. Remember the same can be said for the blood glucose meter. They are slightly inaccurate -- with some variance even in repeated tests. This has to due with some variance in the testing materials, etc.
The good reading is 4-5.9% for healthy people, 8+ % for diabetics. You want to below 6.5-7% to be considered OK.
Getting a 4.1 or 4.8 really does not matter. Both are quite healthy. If you want to spend time going to the lab, waiting, get the draw, wait two weeks for results; yes, the results will be more accurate.
|