Quote:
Originally Posted by tuscany
An interesting thing I have noticed is that I have not come across any vegetarian who has made goal...unless thay are just not posting. So there is no "role model" that I can look to & say "yes, it is possible" Its all a maybe in my head still
|
Well, I can help you there...
First, before I was diagnosed with cancer last spring, I had legitimately lost around 45 lbs on PP (not exactly sure of my starting weight...it was at least 212, but I didn't own a scale at the time.) That loss put me at 168, around 20lbs to my goal of between 145-150. I say 'legitimately' because I had no symptoms until about three months before my diagnosis, and my weight loss was basically a pretty normal pathway down from somewhere around 212 to 168 before I got sick.
I was meatless for extended periods of time in that phase, from starting the plan in Feb 2002 until my diagnosis in April, 2004. I say meatless because I did and do eat fish, have since I went meatless in the early 70s. My religion considers fish 'abstinence from meat,' and since I'm not and never have been a vegetarian for philosophical reasons, that works for me.
On PP in my dieting phase, I would occasionally include poultry or meat from warm-blooded animals in two to three meals per week, but the rest of the meals and snacks for the week were meatless.
Now, if you want someone stricter than that to consider a 'role model,' I commend you to Rose Elliot (she just authored a vegetarian low carb cookbook available from amazon.com.uk, and to Cindy Norman (now Norwitz), who has been vegetarian/vegan for years, has followed Protein Power for years, and who, prior to her recent pregnancy, had been at and maintained her goal weight for years. Now, post pregnancy, she is working on losing the balance of baby weight to get back to her original pre-pregnancy goal weight. Cindy also ate some level of fish in the beginning, but in the time I've known her in cyberspace, she has been mainly vegan, occasionally eating some eggs or a little dairy. She runs Immune-web, and hosts the lc-veg mailing list.
Yeah, it can be done. But you have to really be focused, and you HAVE to be willing to exercise and to reshape your body at the same time that you're feeding it. My 145-150 goal weight was based on a projected 26% body fat, and a 118-120 lb. lean body mass. I did intermediate level Pilates with resistance three-four times per week, and walked at least a mile every day, as well as doing two or three 10 minute sessions on the stair machine every week. I know that sounds like a lot of exercise, but it was no more than 30 minutes TOTAL on any given day. The thing is, I exercised nearly every day.
Someone else posted in this thread that exercise is all the difference between a size 6 at a given weight and a size 12, and that's totally true. Right this minute, 9 months after intestinal surgery and enforced no-exercise-but-light-walking, I am back to 203 lbs...but of the few pre-PP clothes I owned, most do NOT fit my abdominal area in any kind of flattering way. Even at 212, my body was tighter and in better shape than I'm in this second. The difference is NOT in what I ate as much as in how much I've been able/allowed to move. And at 168, I had built up my lean body mass so well that I really couldn't possibly have gotten down to what the Met Life Insurance charts say a five foot tall woman should weigh...unless I cut off an appendage.
I am also 50 years old, started PP when I was 47. Although I wasn't menopausal prior to chemo, I was definitely in perimenopause and am in menopause now until the drugs stop. There's a lot to be said for maintaining a slightly higher body fat percentage (say, 26%, rather than 22%) as you pass into your 30s and 40s.
Now my LBM has dropped, due to lack of exercise, to about 99 lbs. But my frame and age and hormone levels are such that they will still keep me from ever getting to a body weight much lower than 130 lbs. And since I can now exercise more, I'm looking forward to building back that LBM to at least a more respectable 110 lbs or so.
And btw, for what it's worth...cutting fats is not going to help your blood lipid profile, which is a benefit of low carb eating that goes way beyond immediate weight loss and impacts your level of cardiac event risk. Since cardiac events are one of the leading killers of women, I'd be more concerned about my lipid levels than about whether I was a size 12 or a size 6 in my 130 lb five foot tall body. YMMV.
Gaelen