Fri, Oct-02-09, 15:46
|
|
Registered Member
Posts: 2,886
|
|
Plan: Dr Dahlqvist's
Stats: 205/152/160
BF:
Progress: 118%
|
|
I went back and checked through the comments to see if mine had been accepted.
But I was more interested in reading some of the others I though this one particularly interesting as I tried to find out how to contact Professor Fairweather-Tait to explain why I was annoyed by the report. This is what he got as a reply.
As the statement, taking more than 400IU of vitamin D per day can be lethal, is totally inaccurate and alarming, I contacted Professor Fairweather-Tait. In response Professor Fairweather-Tait and another lady (presumably her secretary/assistant ) responded as follows:
"I don't know anything about this article or who to contact. I certainly didn't say what I'm reported as saying. I remember talking to a journalist many weeks ago about infant formula in the UK that was provided (just after WW2) to low income mothers, which was fortified with vit D, and actually caused the death of one or more babies because the wrong amount of vit D had been added. I used this to illustrate the concerns in the UK about the potential dangers of giving too much vit D."
She also copied me on the following e-mail she sent to the Daily Mail journalist:
"There is an error in the quoted upper level of vitamin D and I have been contacted and asked to request a correction .........................."
- Alan Ruth, Greystones, County Wicklow, 16/9/2009 12:08
So I bit of creative editing had been going on that attributed to this scientist words she had never said. Looks like the moron was the journalist.
PS Pleased to note the standard of replies was better than some I've had to deal with to recently. But we still need more people to participate in these online comments boards. I know it's tedious but unless people who have some understanding of the science contradict the rubbish that is printed the more journalists can think they can get away with writing utter tosh.
Last edited by Hutchinson : Fri, Oct-02-09 at 15:51.
|