Java,

Personally, I prefer the natural peanut butters. After being on LC for a while, they just seem to have a warmer, richer and nuttier taste.

The grocery store I shop at (Publix- a Southeast chain that started in Florida) makes their own fresh in the deli section. It is so good.

Some people also make their own with a food processor. If you wanted it sweet but did not want sugar, you could always add Splenda. Just a thought.