Except a lot of CAs react to fiber, therefore it doesn't matter about how less calorically dense broccoli is than a chocolate ice cream bar. AS has NO calories and many CAs react to that too. It's not about the calories. It's about the carbs and a CAs unique insulin reaction. It can even be about a perceived sweet taste or smell. We do NOT have the same reaction to carbs and fiber as others. And you know that net carb theory doesn't apply in CAD.

I also think that the Hellers' books tie nicely to specific situations. CAD for the younger crowd; CALP for the over 40s and those with sensitivities; Carb Addicted Kids for their parents addressing the special situations of kids, Heart Healthy is obvious and now, 7 Day Low Carb rescue for those who know they need low carb but just can't seem to get started. They all seem pretty relevant to me.

Everyone is entitled to his/her own perceptions though.